THE STRUGGLE ISRAEL
The death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar marks a major symbolic victory for Israel, and creates an opportunity for the country to change its approach to the war in Gaza. But it hardly signals the end of the regional conflict Sinwar helped ignite.
- Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar, mastermind of the brutal October 7 attack, was killed during a chance encounter with Israeli troops in the southern part of the Gaza Strip on Wednesday, Israel announced. Sinwar’s death caps an intense, year-long manhunt by Israeli forces that contributed to the decimation of Gaza. In the end, he was found by a group of trainee squad commanders who encountered him unexpectedly while on a routine patrol, according to the New York Times. He was later identified by his DNA and dental records.
- Sinwar led both Hamas’s military and political wings after Israel assassinated the group’s previous top political official, and had been accused by the United States of seeking to widen the war in the Middle East. He’s been a key decision-maker for Hamas since the start of the conflict, and in recent rounds of fruitless ceasefire negotiations. With Sinwar gone, Israelis have effectively forced a change-up in their adversary’s negotiating team.
- Democrats and Republicans hailed Sinwar’s departure from the world stage as a major step forward for peace. But experts and officials aren’t so certain. “Hamas is not going to disappear as an organization, no more than Hezbollah” did after Israel killed its leader last month, former Middle East peace negotiator Aaron David Miller told What A Day. One important question mark is who replaces Sinwar at the negotiating table. If it’s Mohammed Sinwar, his similarly hardline brother, “negotiations are totally screwed,” an American official told CNN.
It’s also less than clear that the current Israeli government is set on negotiating a ceasefire deal, no matter who takes Sinwar’s place.
- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is facing corruption charges, has been repeatedly accused of prolonging the war for his own political gain. Another Israeli leader with the strategy might actually conclude this is a moment to begin seriously talking about de-escalating the war,” Miller said. “He’ll talk about ‘total victory,’ the need to continue to achieve total to de-radicalize Gaza, crush the remaining Hamas forces that exist.”
- But Netanyahu now has an off-ramp — and faces a crucial decision whether to take it, according to Jeremy Ben-Ami, president of the liberal pro-Israel advocacy group J Street. Escalating tensions with Iran and Hezbollah militants in Lebanon probably won’t cool down anytime soon. Sinwar’s death represents a prime opportunity for Israel to change direction in Gaza, if it wants to, he said. “A rational and sane government of Israel would take this as the moment to pivot and bring this thing to an end,” Ben-Ami told What A Day.
- One looming concern: What will happen to the hostages remaining in Gaza? The families of hostages pressed Netanyahu’s government to use the moment to quickly secure a deal to release their loved ones. Vice President Kamala Harris called for an end to the war today. Now, the U.S. needs to bring together other countries to pressure Netanyahu to make a deal, said Liz Naftali, the great aunt of a hostage who was released last year. “This is a country that, until the hostages come back, cannot start to heal and move forward,” she told What A Day in a phone call from Israel.
The U.S. doesn’t know what Sinwar’s death means yet for the future of the war in Gaza, an American official told CNN. A ceasefire or hostage deal could happen soon — or “there could still be a long path ahead,” the official said.
MITCH, PLEASE
McConnell reminded us that Trump’s highest-profile backers know exactly who he is — and we know that for certain, because they’ve said so. Today, McConnell effectively called Vance and Graham hypocrites. But McConnell is also still endorsing Trump this year. So, he’s right! They are “all on the same team now.”
Want more?
NEWS NEWS NEWS
Nearly half of young people say they’d have a more negative view of someone they go on a date with if the person is a Trump supporter, according to a new poll. I can’t believe kids these days don’t want to date someone who supports a racist, misogynistic, sex predator convicted of felonies!
